Youth PlugJua rada. Know what’s up.
Plugging in
Get Plugged
Notebook
Reflections23 JAN 2026 · 7 MIN READ

Happy New Year To All Except The Excel Sheet!

This year we are sharing our growth journey: the good, the bad, the ugly. Genuinely and unashamedly. Because we ought to stop the performance.

The Youth Plug teamMalindi, Kenya
A tired man holding his head at a desk piled with files next to a spreadsheet

Hello friend, and happy new year! We hope that your 2026 is off to a bright and hopeful start.

You’ve felt it too, haven’t you? The stir caused by that last sentence. With everything happening all around us and in the world, talking about optimism tugs strangely at the heart, causing a tightening in the chest. And yet, we cannot give in to dejection. We, individually and collectively, must constantly remind ourselves that we have the power to shape our lives and experiences, and act accordingly. Because we do.

We came back to the office this week, having taken our month long annual break that began on the 19th of December last year. It is quite literally the only time we get to really rest: actually close our laptops, not look at our emails or think extensively about “work”. It is this way because, at the moment, we do not take leave during the year. Our team is small and fits together as tightly as a jigsaw, where the absence of one person leaves a gap that affects our normal operations. Naturally, we are usually burnt out by November, so the four week break at the end of the year is much anticipated and very welcome. We aspire towards systems that allow us more rest.

Being swallowed by the system

There’s plenty on our minds right now, but what takes up much bandwidth is the structure of the nonprofit sector within which we are embedded. Having been here for four years now, something feels off. When we came in, we were excited because we had ideas, many of which were unconventional. We had identified a gap in the sector: too many organisations are speaking to themselves and to their donors, instead of to the people they are meant to serve.

This shapes them like departments of funder organisations and, to local communities, like foreigners. This carries with it the pretence and suspicion that is extended to outsiders. It is no wonder, then, that their projects lack community ownership and that they struggle to raise local support, which is more sustainable than unpredictable external funding cycles.

We saw how we would come in and improve this situation by doing “crazy” social marketing projects, both for ourselves and in support of other nonprofits, just like they do in the for profit sector. We would make complex social issues connect with people and, as a result, inspire real attitude and behaviour change, increase visibility for organisations, build local support and make it easier for them to raise funds.

If our idea cannot be sequentially arranged in a log frame and measured in numbers, then it does not make sense, and therefore cannot be funded.

But our enthusiasm was soon put to a halt by “the system”. We started hitting guardrails that oriented us towards order, conformity and predictability, and away from creativity and innovation. If the intervention we suggest is not physical and rational, we have to go back to the drawing board, because here, other value such as psychological value does not fit.

Trapped between donor driven structures and messy realities

The problem begins at the funding level, where more than 90% of NPO budgets come from foreign sources. And because the one who pays the piper calls the tune, there is not much autonomy left to grantees. To win, one has to align with the ever changing priorities of the donor, navigate processes and templates, and use language that has been predetermined by funders, or that is likely to appease them. We spend a lot of time and energy getting it “exactly right”, because one is better off presenting perfection and absolute compliance than not. The result is fear and the death of authenticity.

When the contract comes, an organisation has to build elaborate compliance and reporting systems to satisfy different donors. It gets so hectic that some even set up compliance departments. Inadvertently, internal hierarchies develop that complicate processes that would otherwise be easy.

Along the way, even the reason the organisation was set up becomes blurry to the team, for the funder will define the problem, the success and even the timeframe. They also define the language, and in doing so it loses some of its local meaning and nuance. As we know, the way we name something affects how we address it. Gradually, the organisation envisioned by the founder, and the problem they were trying to solve, morphs into something else, which is not necessarily better. And then, to extend contracts, executives have to perpetually curry favour, even if by hiding failures or misrepresenting pressing issues.

The Excel sheet

But the thing that has terrified us most is the Excel sheet. It is, in our view, the grand tool of control. Upon it an organisation’s mission, culture, size and perceived success depend. We have seen how it can cause an organisation whose mission is to address mental health among adolescents to suddenly pivot to climate change. We have been accosted by ratios and percentages that, to some extent, make sense, but are far too rigid to accommodate the diverse and contextual nature of this work.

For example, because overhead and administrative costs are tightly capped by funders, organisations underinvest in staff development, the very people doing the work, and so the overall impact of the project is weakened. A good office, good tools and equipment, retreats for reflection and staff wellbeing initiatives all shape how people think, collaborate and execute. Yet this value, which cannot be entered into an Excel sheet or measured in numbers, is hardly factored in.

The system has also demanded of us easily measurable “quick wins”. Complex, long term projects seem unwelcome. Right after the extremely linear, cause and effect log frame, one is required to show a work plan, which often already comes with a funder imposed timeframe. And if one is asked to propose the timeline themselves, the heart beats a little faster and fingers hover over the keys they know are actually right. If one has a friend on the donor side, they call to ask, “How long do you think we should put?” If not, they type the most conservative numbers. This, in turn, alters how the project is executed, dilutes its impact and shapes how the organisation is perceived by the community.

All of this happens in the office. On the ground, it has devastating effects on the long term work of an NPO. The most obvious is weak ownership of projects, which you will know when you hear community members say, “This is an organisation’s borehole,” instead of “This is our borehole.”

Short funding cycles cause projects to end or collapse quickly, creating a sense of coming and going and bringing into question the real motives of nonprofits. It makes it look like they do these projects to benefit themselves more than the communities they serve.

This quick turnover also causes NGO fatigue within communities, affecting people’s willingness to take part in new programs. When we were starting the Kibaraza program in Malindi, which helps grassroots creatives create more, create better and earn from their work, a hesitant young person told us: “We have seen many organisations like you come here with projects similar to this, but when you look around, nothing has changed!” This concern is widely shared.

The erosion of trust

The biggest effect of all these structural barriers is the erosion of trust. Here is how:

  • Trust within oneself: “Is this what I want, what I set out to do?”
  • Trust within an organisation: “Are we really doing meaningful work?”
  • Trust amongst nonprofits: “Let’s hoard socially beneficial information to remain competitive.”
  • Trust between organisations and funders: in the performance of appearing neat and compliant, things sometimes slip, and failure cannot be hidden for long. Funders grow frustrated that they keep providing support and yet programs fail to yield the desired outcome.
  • Trust between nonprofits and the communities they serve: “These organisations come and go year after year and nothing changes. They serve themselves, not us.”

Please note that we are not entirely blaming funders; we funded organisations also have our role in this situation. And we are not saying that everything is set up wrong. We are saying there has to be more conversation and action, from all players, towards adjusting a few things in this system. For a start, the emphasis on formality and perfection, on neat log frames and the dreaded Excel sheet, should make room for creativity, novelty and unconventionality. There are many good ideas and solutions that cannot be typed into, or even anticipated by, spreadsheets, but we will never know them if our attitude is risk aversion.

In the next post, we shall expand this thought further. In the meantime, if you work in the sector, do you share this feeling? Tell us in the comments below or email us at dm@youthplug.org.

Keep reading.

Get plugged.

Partner with us

The most powerful investment in Kenya's youth is a mindset shift. Let's partner in the work that makes all other work possible.

Tuongee. Email us

Fuel the mission

Your support funds the thing that makes lasting change possible: a shift in how young people see themselves and their power.

Donate